A misleading ad doesn’t become someone else’s problem just because an agency wrote it. This post looks at what the Australian Consumer Law actually requires from the agency itself, alongside the business whose name is on the campaign.
Most compliance conversations in marketing focus on the client’s obligations. What a solicitor can claim, what a business can promise, what a testimonial needs before it’s published. The agency drafting the words is treated as a service provider passing along a finished product, with the legal exposure sitting entirely on the other side of the relationship.
That assumption doesn’t hold up.
The agency carries its own exposure
The Australian Consumer Law’s prohibition on misleading or deceptive conduct applies to anyone acting in trade or commerce, including the agency creating the advertising alongside the business it promotes. The bar for that isn’t simply having drafted the ad. Two Full Federal Court appeal decisions, the MBF Case and the NRMA Case, established that an agency is generally liable for misleading conduct only where it acted recklessly, negligently, or specifically appreciated that the advertisement conveyed a misleading representation.1 Authorship alone doesn’t establish liability. Actual knowledge of the facts making the claim misleading does.
A Federal Court case against Advanced Medical Institute fits that standard precisely: the court declared that the company’s advertising agent was knowingly concerned in the contravention, for preparing and publishing advertisements the agent knew contained misleading representations, independent of the client’s own liability.2 Knowledge, not mere involvement, is what closed the gap between the agency and the outcome.
This runs on a separate track from a solicitor’s own responsibility under the legal profession’s conduct rules. Rule 36 attributes responsibility to the solicitor connected to the practice. The ACL adds a second, independent layer on top of that, reaching the agency directly.
Neither layer replaces the other, and neither makes the other redundant. Rule 36 doesn’t transfer a solicitor’s obligation to the agency, and an agency’s ACL exposure doesn’t transfer the agency’s liability to the solicitor. Two different regulators can act on the same piece of content for two different reasons: the Legal Services Commissioner considering the solicitor’s conduct, and the ACCC considering the agency’s. A firm relying entirely on its own review as the only safeguard is carrying that weight alone. A firm working with an agency that has its own independent legal reason to catch a problem gets a second set of eyes with its own genuine motivation behind it, beyond a contractual promise to be careful.
Where this shows up in practice
The ACCC’s own review of testimonials and endorsements found a substantial majority of the social media content it examined raised concerns under the ACL, and found similar issues across more than a third of the businesses reviewed.3 The pattern wasn’t limited to the business posting the content. Anyone involved in creating or publishing a misleading claim carries a share of that exposure.
For a marketing agency, that reaches further than the finished ad. A testimonial published without documented consent, a specialisation claim inserted because it reads well, an outcome promise added to make copy feel more persuasive: each of these is a decision made during drafting, before the client ever sees the final version. The agency that made that drafting decision remains exposed once it’s published, alongside the client.
What this means for how content gets approved
An agency that takes this seriously builds review into the drafting process itself, treating client sign-off as one checkpoint among several. That means checking specialisation claims against actual accreditation before they’re written, holding testimonials until consent is documented, and treating a client’s enthusiasm for a stronger claim as a prompt to slow down and check it first.
None of this replaces a client’s own review. It sits alongside it, because the exposure sits with both parties regardless of which one happens to notice a problem first.
An agency’s obligations under the Australian Consumer Law start at the first draft, well before a client ever signs off.
If you’re weighing how a prospective agency actually reviews its own work before it reaches you, start a conversation about how content gets approved. This is the standard Jane Cluff applies to everything published for a client.
Frequently asked
Is a marketing agency liable under the Australian Consumer Law, or only the business it works for?
Both can be liable. Liability isn’t automatic. A Federal Court case against Advanced Medical Institute found the company’s advertising agent was knowingly concerned in the contravention, independent of the client’s own liability. Two earlier Full Federal Court decisions established that an agency is generally liable only where it acted recklessly, negligently, or knew the advertisement was misleading, drafting the content on its own isn’t enough to trigger it.
Does Rule 36 mean a law firm doesn’t need to worry about its marketing agency’s own compliance?
No. Rule 36 and the ACL operate independently. Rule 36 attributes responsibility to the solicitor and doesn’t transfer to the agency, and an agency’s ACL exposure doesn’t transfer to the solicitor. Both apply to the same piece of content at once, for different reasons and to different parties.
Can an agency avoid liability by saying the client approved the content?
Client approval doesn’t remove the agency’s own exposure for content it created. The ACL’s misleading conduct prohibition applies to anyone acting in trade or commerce, including the agency that drafted and published the claim.
What should a business check before trusting an agency’s compliance practices?
Whether the agency reviews claims during drafting, before a client ever sees them. Catching problems only at sign-off leaves too much to chance. Specific practices like holding testimonials until consent is documented are a stronger signal than a general assurance of compliance.
This post is for informational purposes only and describes Felicity Jane Digital’s own working standard. It does not constitute legal advice and does not advise any reader on their own obligations under the Australian Consumer Law. Firms and agencies should confirm their specific position with their own legal adviser. Current as at 13 October 2026.
References
1. Holding Redlich, Advertising agencies and the law: Liability for the content of advertisements (part 4). Analysis of Cassidy v Saatchi & Saatchi Australia Pty Ltd [2004] FCAFC 34 and Medical Benefits Fund of Australia Ltd v Cassidy [2003] FCAFC 289, establishing that an advertising agency is generally liable for misleading conduct only where reckless, negligent, or specifically aware of the misleading representation. ↩
2. Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Federal Court declares Advanced Medical Institute’s advertising ‘misleading’. Confirms the Federal Court declared AMI’s advertising agent knowingly concerned in the contravention for preparing and publishing the advertisements. ↩
3. Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, Social media influencer testimonials and endorsements. Findings of the ACCC’s December 2023 internet sweep of 118 social media influencers and 137 businesses. ↩
Jane Cluff is the founder of Felicity Jane Digital, a legal SEO agency for Queensland law firms. She studied psychology and urban and regional planning, and has worked in digital marketing since 2014.